Paying taxes is an integral part of the UK’s financial and legal system, for it ensures that individuals and businesses make a fair contribution to public services and national development. Any business or individual engaged in buying and selling assets (either frequently or occasionally) must be mindful of how their activities are classified for tax purposes. Notably, HMRC has its indicators or tests to determine whether an activity constitutes a trade and is therefore subject to taxation. This brings the badges of trade into the picture.
Thus, in this blog, we will explain all the essentials pivoting around HMRC’s 9 badges of trade to help you understand how they apply to your activities and tax obligations.
What are HMRC’s badges of trade?
It is important for HMRC to evaluate when an activity is considered a trade for tax purposes.
To help HMRC determine whether an activity constitutes a trade, it has a set of rules or criteria known as the badges of trade.
Simply put, the trade framework’s badges are a tool to ease the process for taxpayers (individuals or businesses) who are unsure whether the income generated by their business activity is taxable under corporation tax, income tax or capital gains tax and if it even qualifies as a trade in the first place.
Primarily, HMRC has nine badges of trade: a set of nine indicators used to determine whether a person is trading or investing. Notably, while traders are liable to pay income tax, investors are subject to capital gains tax.
Why are badges of trade significant?
The badges of trade ensure that the taxpayers comply with the UK tax laws. Badges of trade help HMRC distinguish between investments, hobbies, or genuine business activities. Now, if their activity amounts to trading, they will be liable to pay Income Tax or Corporation Tax on their income, depending on their business structure.
Having a clear understanding of badges of trade, businesses can optimise tax payments. Similarly, these badges also help advisors guide clients as per the legal principles.
Taking a comprehensive look to understand HMRC’s 9 badges of trade
It is worth emphasising here that these badges are merely a flexible framework and not strict guidelines. Subsequently, no single badge can ensure one’s exact trading status. On the contrary, HMRC takes a holistic approach by taking into account all relevant factors. The following are the HMRC’s 9 badges of trade to give you adequate clarity on what they are and how they apply to your business activities:
1. Profit-seeking motive
The profit motive is often deemed the most crucial badge or pointer to indicate a trade. When acquiring an asset, if your main goal is to resell it for profit, it will likely be interpreted as trading.
Although not every trade is conducted with the intention of earning profit, the persistent indication of a profit-focused approach can substantiate the case for trading status.
For instance, Lisa is a skilled baker and starts selling homemade cakes and pastries at a weekend food fair. Initially, she claims this is just a hobby. However, HMRC may consider it a trade if she:
- Keeps elaborate financial records
- Sets prices strategically to keep the profit margin.
- Regularly promoting business through digital and print marketing.
2. The frequency of transactions
The frequency of transactions can be a key indicator of trading if:
- A large volume of transactions is being made.
- Frequent and similar transactions hold more volume than sales, which are diverse and unrelated.
- A trading pattern can be established through regular intervals between transactions.
3. The nature of the asset
You might be considered a trader if the item being sold is typically associated with trading, such as commodities and goods. Products intended for personal use, such as family heirlooms, are less likely to qualify due to the lack of commercial intent.
This badge focuses on whether an asset or item is being sold.
- Has a commercial value
- Has been sold for a profit
If so, it will fall under the category of trading.
4. Existence of similar trading transactions or interests
This badge scrutinises whether the individual selling an item also conducts trade in similar items, or if he has the relevant expertise in that asset. It considers Hobby vs. Business, such as if similar hobbies are carried out using business-like ways
Hobby vs. Business:
Alternatively, when your trading transactions are associated with your existing trade or established business, they strongly point towards trading.
For instance, Robert is a home decor retailer, and if he decides to sell candles, there lies a stronger link to his existing business. Apart from that, he can also utilise his expertise and customer base to secure better sales. Therefore, HMRC will classify Robert’s transactions as a trade.
5. Changes to the asset
It is yet another significant indicator of the badges of trade in taxation. If a person modifies, alters, or adapts an asset primarily to increase its commercial value or make it more sellable, HMRC will likely regard it as a trading motive.
Furthermore, the following are the indicative questions you must take into consideration to know whether you are trading:
- Did you make changes deliberately to uplift its market value?
- Did you incur any expenses to increase the item’s saleability?
- Was specialist expertise involved in the modification of the asset?
If yes, you are trading and are therefore liable to pay tax.
6. The circumstances of sale
HMRC considers multiple factors to analyse it:
- Whether the sales are made through established marketplaces.
- Whether there is a dedicated online store or website
- Whether sales are actively promoted through email marketing, social media or other channels
- Whether the interactions with customers are conducted in a professional manner.
A one-off sale made in unforeseen circumstances does not indicate an intentional motive to gain profit and will not be considered a trade.
7. Length of ownership
Under this badge, HMRC considers the duration or interval between the purchase and sale of an asset, such as how long the asset was held or owned before it was sold.
To clarify, if you sell an item shortly after its acquisition, this short-term retention or ownership indicates trading. A trader tends not to retain an asset for a long period, as they pursue a quick profit based on fluctuating market conditions, unlike an investor.
8. The source of finance
The source of finance badge examines the intention of funding and the risks associated with the activity. HMRC considers the activity as trading if:
- The funds were borrowed to purchase the assets
- The financing structure suggests the expectations of profit and the associated risk of loss
- Is there any evidence of reinvestment of initial capital to purchase additional assets or expand business operations?
It might also be relevant to highlight here that although a buy-to-let property is often funded through loans, the repayments come primarily from letting or rental income. Therefore, no trading is indicated in this case.
9. Method of acquisition
It is the final test or criterion among the badges of trade. It shows how the asset was acquired. For instance, if you have obtained an asset by inheritance, such as a family heirloom, or you have received a gift, it is unlikely to suggest trading.
Final word
All in all, it is of utmost importance for taxpayers to comprehend HMRC’s badges of trade, not only for staying compliant but also to make careful tax decisions. Whether you are running a side hustle, investing in property, or trading in goods, these indicators are vital in clarifying your tax position before HMRC and avoiding penalties. Eventually, with badges of trade, you can recognise how your activities are likely to be classified and steer clear of unforeseen tax responsibilities.
Additional Resources:
